Welcome to

A jury in Tallahassee has found one person guilty of first degree murder in the slaying of an FSU law professor, but it could not come to a unanimous decision in the case of a woman co conspirator.

The family of slain law professor Dan Markel left the courtroom without talking to reporters.

Prosecutor Georgia Cappleman said the family is pleased with the verdict, despite the jury being unable to come to a unanimous decision on codefendant Katherine Magbanua.

“It’s been a long road and I’m really happy to get the beginnings of some justice for the Markel family,” said Cappleman. “They’re happy, they’re very happy.”

Katherine Magbanua cried as she heard the jury could not agree on murder charges against her.

The father of Magbanua’s children Sigfredo Garcia now faces the death penalty.

“I think that she had been reserving her emotional aspect for a long time and it reached its tipping point,” said Garcia’s Attorney Saam Zangeneh. “You know, and listen to what she just heard. That the father of her children may be put to death.”

Jurors did convict Sigfredo Garcia on a conspiracy.

The only conspirators named in the trial were the family of the slain law professor’s ex-wife, though no charges have been brought against the family at this time.

Cappleman described the verdicts as a good start, despite failing to get a conviction for Magbanua.

When asked if now-convicted Sigfredo Garcia might cooperate to save himself from the death penalty and to save the mother of his children Cappleman said it wasn’t her call to make.

“I don’t do the reaching out. He’s represented by council so I don’t reach out to folks that are represented by council. They’ll have to let me know if that’s what they want to do,” said Cappleman.

Magbanua will remain in jail where she’s been for three years.

A hearing in her case is set for later this month.

A hearing on whether Sigfredo Garcia will receive the death penalty will be held on Monday.

Busing for many Florida students will soon be going green thanks to money from the Volkswagen emissions settlement.

The Florida Department of Environmental Protection announced $166 million will be made available to help schools transition from diesel to electric school buses.

Environmentalists like Aliki Moncrief are applauding the move.

“Making sure that our kids have buses that aren’t spewing toxic chemicals right into their air space, making sure that our kids and our schools are kind of at the leading edge of a clean energy economy with electric buses I think is a really wise choice,” said Moncrief.

Exactly how the funds will be divvied up has not been decided yet.

DEP could cover 100 percent of the cost of new electric buses, or possibly cover a part of the cost to stretch the funds further.

The fates of two people accused of killing an FSU professor are now in the hands of twelve jurors.

Prosecutors urged the jury not to be swayed by the fact that those ultimately responsible are not in the courtroom.

Prosecutors began their two hour summation pinning the blame squarely on the family of Dan Markel’s ex wife.

“What enemy or enemies had Mr. Markel made that set into motion such a brutal act? The answer: his own family,” said Prosecutor Georgia Cappleman.

For three weeks the government has played wiretaps and a video referred to as the bump, where an undercover FBI agent hands a note to Donna Adelson, Dan Markel’s ex-mother-in-law, and then recorded who talked to whom.

“She goes straight to Charlie Adelson who goes straight to Katherine Magbanua, who goes goes straight to Sigfredo Garcia. Exactly what this undercover operation was designed to ferret out,” said Cappleman.

But Cappleman told jurors that justice for anyone not in the courtroom would have to wait for another day.

“We are all trusting you to render a wise and legal verdict in this case,” said Cappleman.

Defense lawyers did their best to try and shift the blame to someone else.

Accused triggerman Sigfredo Garcia’s lawyer tried to shift the blame to Luis Rivera, the gang kingpin who became the government’s key witness.

“A gangster killed Dan Markel. Luis Rivera killed Dan Markel,” said attorney Saam Zangeneh.

The lawyer for Katherine Magbanua turned the attention back to the Adelson’s.

“They tried to build a case around her. To force her to cooperate, so they could get what they have been going after for years now, the Adelson family,” said Attorney Chris DeCoste.

The jury got the case just before 4 pm.

The Adelson’s have not been charged with any crime and they deny any involvement in the Markel murder.

The case is going to be the subject of at least two national news magazines shows in the coming weeks.

Both Dateline NBC and 20/20 are working on the true crime story.

Hurricane Michael made landfall one year ago Thursday and the longest recovery will likely be for those in the timber industry.

For timber farmer Mathew Stokes the one year anniversary of Hurricane Michael conjures up painful memories.

“Thinking of those three or four hours we spent in the tub sweating with the power off waiting for it to pass,” said Stokes.

And when the winds subsided…

“The whole world changed,” said Stokes.

The biggest hit was to Mathew’s tree farming company, Neal Land & Timber in Blountstown.

Using a drone Mathew showed us the damage to one of his thousand acre plots, which was a total loss.

“It’s just getting more and more expensive everyday it seems like, but we’re trying to go forward and get good growth out of our trees,” said Stokes.

In all, his company owns 45,000 acres across six counties.
“We’re well up over $30 million worth of lost timber on the stump,” said Stokes.

The timber industry took a $1.3 billion hit from Michael.

Unlike other crops, timber is essentially uninsurable.

Even worse for many it’s a living 401K.

“I’ve talked to a lot of people who said you know this was my retirement plan,” said Blountstown City Manager Traci Hall.

Hall said the impacts to the timber industry haven’t even fully manifested.

“We have a lot of people that are going to be jobless once everything is cleaned up,” said Hall.

Mathew believes government reimbursement could help, but told us at the end of the day there’s no silver bullet.

“We’re just going to have to work through it and do the best we can,” said Stokes.

Mathew estimates replanting and regrowth will take between 12 and 15 years, but it could take even longer depending on what level of assistance the federal government agrees to provide.

Mathew added while the road ahead will certainly be challenging, he’s hopeful things will turn out alright in the end.

He’s said he’s just blessed he and his family made it out of the storm alive.

“Thanking God that we lived through it and that we are here to be a part of the recovery process,” said Stokes.

Thursday marks the one year anniversary of Hurricane Michael’s landfall in the Florida Panhandle.

We revisited the small city of Blountstown Florida on the eve of the anniversary to speak with residents and city officials about how recovery has progressed so far.

Michael became the worst disaster to strike Blountstown on October 10th 2018.

City Manager Traci Hall remembers the storm vividly.

“We watched roofs come off of local businesses out the windows. We watched the steeple blow off the methodist church,” said Hall.

Local business owners Edwin and Lynn Strawn rode out the hurricane in their home.

“Watching the trees fall. We just couldn’t believe it,” said Edwin.

Hours later the devastation was obvious.

“We could not see down the street in any direction,” said Edwin.

But the storm united the city under a single cause.

“You know everybody in this community helped everybody in this community,” said Lynn.

While the initial outpouring of support was great, a year later scenes of rotting tarps of homes are all too common.

It’s a constant reminder that recovery over the last year has been slow.

Many structures were uninsured, for others claims have been slow to process.

“You can drive anywhere and see blue tarps, tarps that are coming off of houses, houses that have not been repaired,” said Lynn.

For the city, Federal aid has also been slow.

“We’ve spent over $13 million on this storm and are waiting on reimbursement,” said Hall.

Despite the hardships, the people of Blountstown remain optimistic.

“This community is wonderful, resilient, l very supportive and I know together we can make this happen,” said Hall.

On the anniversary the city will gather for an evening of prayer.

They expect a big crowd.

A testament to the resilience of this community.

Wednesday would have been slain FSU law professor Dan Markel’s 47th birthday.

Instead, the defendant who had the most to gain from taking a plea deal took the stand in Markel’s murder trial.

Rumors swirled around the courthouse Wednesday morning.

A plea deal in the murder was in the works.

Those rumors were quashed when defendant Katherine Magbanua took the stand.

She’s accused of being the conduit between her co-defendat and ex-husband, and the family of the slain professors ex-wife.

“Did you have anything to do with the murder of Dan Markel?” Asked Magbanua’s attorney Tara Kwass.

“No mam,” Magbanua replied.

“Did you get the father of your two children, Mr. Garcia, to commit a murder on behalf of Mr. Charlie Adelson?” Kwass continued.

“No mam,” Mabanua again asserted.

Her lawyers tied to lay the defense that accused trigger man Sigfredo Garcia could have been selling drugs to Charlie Adelson and didn’t need her as a go between.

“Did Mr. Adelson ever do illicit drugs in front of you?” Asked Magbanua’s second attorney Chris DeCoste.

“Did Mr. Adelson? Yes,” replied Magbanua.

When it was the prosecutor Georgia Cappleman’s turn, she drilled down on why Magbanua might not have taken a plea deal.

“Isn’t it true you’ve been offered some kind of big payoff if you refuse to cooperate against Charlie Adelson?” Asked Cappleman.

“If I refused? No mam,” replied Magbanua.

“Has anybody offered you some money?” Asked Cappleman.

“No,” Magbanua replied.

“Do you remember telling anybody that you would be able to stay home after you get acquitted and have a tutor for your kids to be home schooled at the house?” Asked Cappleman.

“No,” Magbanua again replied.

The lawyer for Katherine Magbanua said it was her client’s decision to take the stand.

Wednesday was the first day Dan Markel’s parents have not been at the trial since it began as they observed Yom Kippur.

Before the jury went home Wednesday afternoon.

They were told to pack a bag.

Deliberations are expected to begin Thursday.

After a day and a half of testimony, Federal Judge Robert Hinkle is considering whether or not to temporarily block the law requiring felons pay all fines, fees and restitution before becoming eligible for voting rights restoration under Amendment 4.

Civil rights groups like the ACLU argued the state of Florida is violating the US Constitution by barring voting rights restoration to those who cannot afford to pay.

“The Supreme Court has said over and over again that that’s fundamental, you can’t make it dependent on whether or not you’re rich or poor,” said Orion Danjuma, an attorney with the ACLU.

Danjuma also pointed out patchwork record keeping can make it incredibly difficult for many felons, like plaintiff Pastor Clifford Tyson, to determine what they owe in the first place.

“One paper says one thing, another one says another thing,” said Tyson.

Tyson needed help from attorneys to find he owes at least $50,000 from his past convictions.

“The system that’s in place is entirely broken,” said Danjuma.

The state argued Amendment 4 itself mandates the payment requirements and noted that it’s working to make it easier to determine eligibility.

The judge gave little indication of when or how he might rule, but he closed with a quote from President Ronald Regan: Freedom is never more than one generation away from extinction.

The words struck a chord with Pastor Tyson, who registered to vote before the law was passed, but would lose the right once again if the law stands.

“Because when I got released from prison, that was only the beginning, but it was like that statement took more shackles off of me and so that was was very very personal,” said Tyson.

Judge Hinkle did drop one hint.

He said if either side believes their completely right in this case, they’re fooling themselves.

A trial date has been set for April, but Hinkle suggested multiple times throughout the hearing that he hopes state agencies and the Legislature can work to address many of the systematic issues surrounding felons voting rights restoration without waiting for the courts to force their hand.

The FBI agent who lead the investigation into the murder of an FSU law professor has taken center stage in the trial over most of the last two days.

Defense attorneys are questioning every move the FBI made.

FBI Special Agent Pat Sanford took the stand early Monday and finished shortly after noon on Tuesday.

He faced tough questions about whether the dead law professor’s ex wife’s family was involved in his murder.

“The Adelson’s wanted it to happen right?” Asked attorney for defendant Katherine Magbanua, Chris DeCoste.

“Correct,” replied Sanford.

The lawyers representing Magbanua and co-defendant Sigfredo Garcia are pushing the idea that the FBI overlooked the possibility that the third defendant, Luis Rivera who was facing the death penalty, was the sole perpetrator.

“He became your witness, right?” Asked DeCoste.

“Right,” replied Sanford.

“In exchange for that needle coming out of his arm, right?” DeCoste shot back.

The lawyers also probed whether the FBI came up with a conspiracy theory and sought to prove it rather than just follow the evidence, arguing Magbanua was arrested just a get to the Adelson Family.

“Charles Adelson was just using Katherine just to find out more information about what was going on with the bump, because she’s expendable. He can use her without any risk to himself?” Asked DeCoste.

“Totally disagree with that,” replied Sanford.

Then comments by attorney Chris DeCoste brought the judge’s ire.

“Federal Bureau of Investigation, right?” Asked DeCoste.

“Exactly,” replied Sanford.

“Not the Federal Bureau of Intimidation,” replied DeCoste.

“Mr. DeCoste!” Interjected Judge James Hankinson.

One of the unreported aspects of this trial is that this jury has tough questions of just about every witness.

The questions, asked by the judge on behalf of the jurors suggest the jury will also ask tough questions amongst themselves once they get behind closed doors.

Prosecutors have relied heavily on intercepted text and voice communications, and defense lawyers put an expert on the stand who testified that more than 2,000 text messages were missing from Charlie Adelson’s account.

A federal judge is considering whether or not to temporarily block a law that prohibits felons from getting the right to vote back if they have outstanding fines fees or restitution.

Marching from the Federal Courthouse to a near by church, voting rights activists made their demands clear.

“Protect our vote,” activists chanted.

They’re hoping to overturn a law passed earlier this year, which requires felons pay all fines, fees and restitution before they’re eligible for voting rights restoration.

For many it’s a reminder of Jim Crow policy.

“Our state politicians have enacted a modern day poll tax,” said Melba Pearson, Florida Deputy Director of the ACLU.

An expert witness testifying in the case analyzed half a million felons’ statuses.

Eight out of ten still owed money related to their sentence.

Most between $500 and $5,000.

Rosemary McCoy, a plaintiff in the case, registered to vote before the law was passed.

“I have restitution, but guess what? I was able to register, I was able to vote,” said McCoy. “So how can SB 7066 come back and say the world’s going to end because she voted?”

While the payment requirements have spurred heavy opposition from some, a recent survey found three out of four voters support the law.

In its opening arguments the state pointed to similar laws in Arizona, Alabama and Tennessee that have been held up in court.

The state also noted the option in Florida’s law for fine and fees to be converted to community service if a felon can’t afford to pay.

If the judge does rule to block the law while the case makes its way through the courts it could allow those like McCoy to stay on the rolls, possibly long enough to vote in local elections next month.

“I was shackled. My hands and feet were shackled. Now today, I want to be free,” said McCoy.

Arguments are expected to bleed over into Tuesday.

The judge could issue a ruling at the conclusion of that hearing.

More than four dozen tapes of recorded phone calls were played Monday in the trial of two people accused of murdering an FSU law professor for money.

The case had gone cold until an under cover agent slipped on of the suspects a note back in 2016.

In April 2016 the murder of FSU law professor Dan Markel was almost two years old.

Phone taps on the two people now on trial revealed little.

Sgt. Chris Corbett with the Tallahassee Police Department testified in court the theory behind the case is that Markel’s ex-wifes family coordinated the hit.

The plan, called ‘the bump’, was to have an undercover FBI agent hand Markel’s ex-mother-in-law a note asking for money to help suspect Luis Rivera who was already in jail on drug charges.

“Just want to make sure you take care of what he is going through the way your taking care of Katie,” said the FBI agent in a video of the exchange.

“I think a few minutes after arriving to her condo she calls Charlie Adelson,” said FBI agent Paul Standford.

Charlie Adelson called Katherine Magbanua, the woman charged as being the point person between the hitmen and whoever called for Markel to be murdered.

“99 percent sure when I was talking to her she said it’s mentioned your name,” Charlie Adelson told Magbanua in the wire tap recording.

The next day Charlie Adelson meets with his mother.

“They were very cautious, looking around a lot. They were leaning in close to each other talking very low,” said Sandford.

Eventually, Katherine Magbanua calls Sigfredo Garcia, who is accused of pulling the trigger in the murder.

“You keep telling me you’re going to make a phone call,” Magbana says in the recording.

“I’m making that $%^&^ phone call… I’m going to take care of this %*#& problem,” Garcia responded.

Eventually the undercover number attached to the note given to the Adelsons was called.

“The number was called. They didn’t even pick up,” Charlie Adelson is heard saying in a wire tap.

In a later call Charlie reassures his mother.

“This fishing is all that’s going on and I wouldn’t worry about it at all,” said Charlie in the audio recording.

The two defendants are expected to present their witnesses all day Tuesday.

And the jury is expected to get the case on Wednesday.

An under cover FBI agent took the stand Friday afternoon in the trial of two people accused of murdering an FSU law professor.

The agent was used to create concern among conspirators.

In an effort to find a smoking gun in this case and undercover FBI agent approached Donna Adelson.

She’s the mother of the slain FSU Law Professor’s ex-wife.

In April 2016, more than a month before the first arrest in he Markel murder, an undercover FBI agent approached Donna Adelson.

“We know that your family has been taking care of Katie and her friend for quite some time after your problem up north ad been solved,” said the agent a video of the encounter.

Police believe that she’s at the bottom of a conspiracy to kill her son-in-law, over his refusal to allow the couple’s two children to move to South Florida.

“And I want to let you know that my brother, he’s incarcerated, he helped your family with this problem that you guys had up north and we want to make sure that, he’s going through some rough times and we want to make sure that you take care of what he’s going through the way you’re taking care of Katie,” said the agent.

Friday the FBI agent took the stand.

“Well the purpose of a bump is to approach the target or the individual and try to start a conversation,” said the agent.

What happened next, say prosecutors was a series of conversations among the conspirators.

Those wire taps will be played on Monday.

No one in the Adelson family has been charged in this case and the family through its attorney denies any involvement.

The jury is expected to get the case next week.

How much money would legalizing recreational marijuana generate for the state?

That’s the question before state economists as they consider the potential impacts of a proposed constitutional amendment that would regulate marijuana similar to alcohol.

Their job is to determine how much money it could generate or cost the state if it were to be approved by voters.

“This is a beginning point of all the different governmental things that you’re going to have to have in place for this to work,” said Don Kangston, who represents the Florida House on the Financial Impact Estimating Conference.

Steven Hougland with the Florida Sheriff’s Association testified to economists that legalizing marijuana would impose significant costs related to police K-9s.

“The safest thing to do would be to eliminate the dogs that search for marijuana, which is any drug dog,” said Hougland.

The Division of Business and Professional Regulation, which would be tasked with overseeing the legal cannabis market, also projected high startup costs.

“The staffing projection, that’s 225 full time positions,” said Thomas Philpot with DPBR.

But those costs could be offset by sales.

Economists estimate of the 2 million cannabis-using Floridians over 21, about half would enter the retail market.

However, Amy Baker with the Office of Economic & Demographic Research said the number of those who choose to continue purchasing on the black will largely depend on how heavily the Legislature chooses to tax marijuana.”

In other states the tax rate is between ten and 30 percent.

“If the Legislature comes in and chooses to do more you would probably have fewer people coming out of the black market,” said Baker.

The proposed amendment still has to receive approval from the State Supreme Court and gather more than 600,000 additional signatures before it could go before voters.

Even then, it would need 60 percent voter approval to pass.

Attorney General Ashley Moody has asked the Florida Supreme Court to strike down the proposed amendment, because she believes it is too long and would mislead voters.

There are also two other competing ballot initiatives that would also legalize recreational marijuana.

Two people on trial for murdering an FSU Law Professor for money saw intimate details of their financial lives shared with the jury Friday.

For the last two weeks, the family of the slain FSU law professor Dan Markel has been in the courtroom, listening to every minute of testimony that the jury has been hearing.

They also listened to the nitty gritty as prosecutors try to prove who paid for the hit on their son.

Mary Hull is a forensic accountant who analyzed bank records for the three alleged conspirators as well as the Adelson family, which is suspected of funding the hit.

Of special interest is a Lexus transferred from Harvey Adelson to Katherine Magbanua.

“I could not find any record of a payment,” said Hull.

The records also show confessed hitman Luis Rivera changed his spending habits drastically after the 2014 murder.

“He was not relying on his payroll to provide cash for himself,” said Hull.

The biggest bombshell in those financial records: Katherine Magbanua’s cash deposits soared in the year FSU law professor Dan Markel was murdered and in the two years after..

A police officer also testified that Charlie Adelson, who dated defendant Katherine Magbanau, deleted all of her text messages after she was arrested.

No one in the Adelson Family has been charged and they deny any involvement.

Stacks of cash in a safe and paychecks for a job a woman accused of coordinating the murder of an FSU Professor didn’t have were topics of important testimony Thursday.

Prosecutors are pushing for evidence against the former in-laws of the slain professor.

Convicted murderer turned informant Luis Rivera testified he, Sigfredfo Garcia and Katie Magbanua were paid a $100,000 in cash for killing law professor Dan Markel.

Realtor June Umchinda dated Charlie Adelson, the brother of Markel’s ex-wife, for over a year.

She testified there were large amounts of cash in his bedroom.

“I mentioned he had staples on the hundreds before,” said Umchinada.

The scorned woman was still together with Charlie Adelson when she noticed a change at the time the first arrests were made in 2016.

“He was nervous, and worried, and just not himself,” said Umchinada.

Prosecutors spent a lot of time trying to prove that the alledged go between in the murder for hire got a lot of checks from the Adelson dental office without ever working there.

Dental office employees were visited by the FBI in 2015 seeking payroll records on Katherine Magbanua’s employment.

Assistant Erika Johnson spoke with Charlie in a call no one knew was being recorded.
“I wouldn’t give them anything,” said Johnson.

Then Magbanua’s friend since childhood Yindra Velazquez-Mascara, took the stand.

She testified she was never aware of Magbanua being employed at the Adelson’s office.

Velazquez-Mascara also testified she was asked to keep Magbanua’s kids the night before Dan Markel was murdered, but was never told their father, Sigfredo Garcia.

No member of the Adelson Family has been charged with a crime and the family denies any involvement in the murder of Dan Markel.

Next week marks the one year anniversary of Hurricane Micheal making landfall in the panhandle as a Category 5 storm.

The group Rebuild 850 is painting a bleak picture of the ongoing recovery as it attempts rally public support.

Video taken just days ago shows massive damage from Hurricane Michael still littering the ground.

“The further you get from North West Florida geographically, the less people know that Hurricane Michael even happened,” said Rebuild 850 coordinator Ron Sachs.

But forgetting for those in the panhandle isn’t an option.
“We still have people who are living under blue tarps that are rotting they’re that old,” said Sate Senator Bill Montford.

Shocking statistics including 5,000 homeless, 4,000 lost jobs, eroding tax bases, more than 20,000 outstanding insurance claims and more than $9 billion in uninsured losses barely scratches the surface of the situation in the region.

“When the wind starts blowing these elementary kids in particular start crying,” said Montford.

Rebuild 850 is hoping to put the spotlight back on the panhandle with the one year anniversary of Michael only a week away.

“If these solutions aren’t found in a relatively short period of time you could find yourself with a community that has a hard time ever looking like it did pre-Michael,” said Rebuild 850 co-chair and Former Florida House Speaker Will Weatherford.

Former FEMA Director Craig Fugate said if homes aren’t repaired and rebuilt within five years it could be too late.

He added the onus falls on local, state and federal officials to act boldly and make the money available.

Fugate believes Housing and Urban Development funds are the best option and it’s been done before.

“Louisiana was able to get those dollars to go make direct repairs to damaged homes that didn’t have insurance,” said Fugate.

Locals fear recovery will continue be placed on the back burner if public support remains scarce.

Rebuild 850 has raised more than $600,000, which has been donated to Volunteer Florida to help with recovery efforts.

If you’d like to make a donation visit Rebuild850.org.